Amazon has basically admitted some of you bailed on The Rings of Power, and they’re telling you to just start at season three. Like starting Star Wars at episode four. So Nick Polk and I sounded the horn of Gondor and recorded the on-ramp: everything you need to know before season three, plus a guided tour of the inside jokes from our 26 hours of talking about the first two. This is also, officially, the Waldreg memorial and/or eschatological hope livestream. You may not know who Waldreg is. He made Mordor. We’ll get to that.
Nick walks through the time-compressed Second Age: sexy Sauron as Halbrand, then as Annatar the Lord of Gifts, and Celebrimbor forging the rings and dying for it. From there we hit the show’s best moves, especially how it gets Tolkien’s big theme right. Every villain starts out wanting to fix something good, then reaches for a shortcut. Adar, the most morally serious character in the series, makes every orc slaughter in Middle-earth complicated. Then we make our season three predictions: a Sauron-versus-Balrog fight with Morgoth’s crown, Gandalf redeeming the Dark Wizard, Sauron surrendering to Númenor, and which Númenórean most deserves to become the Nazgûl who sucks. Get me the meat and give it to me raw.
Highlights from the conversation
- Justice for Waldreg. The creepy barkeep with the growing sword who turned the key that made Mordor, the Bird and Baby Easter egg behind his bar, and why his resurrection should open season three.
- Celebrimbor and Annatar. Flattery, isolation, and desire turned inward. The show does what Peter Jackson tried and missed with Gollum, Sam, and Frodo: Sauron’s real power is making your worst desire look like the solution to your biggest problem.
- Damrod and the music. A hill troll, a burst of symphonic death metal, and why Bear McCreary earned a spot on a Howard Shore playlist. Plus the Harfoot song, the Tom Bombadil song, and the Númenor theme.
- Adar and the orcs. One of the first elves, twisted by Morgoth, who wants a homeland for his children. If orcs have families, every heroic orc-slaying gets morally complicated.
- The trouble with Númenor. Peak human civilization with suspiciously few ships, Pharazôn’s resentment of death, the Faithful, and Nick’s prediction: Sauron surrenders at the end of season three, Númenor falls in four, the Last Alliance in five.
- Who gets the rings? Kemen, obviously, as the Nazgûl who never accomplishes anything. And resurrected Waldreg as the Witch-king.
- Galadriel and Sauron. Not a ship, a seduction of power. Adar telling Galadriel she only needs a mirror to find Morgoth’s successor, and why her growth toward the Lady of Lórien is the point.
- Gandalf and the Dark Wizard. My head canon that he’s a Blue Wizard Gandalf redeems and sends east, which is why we never hear about him again.
- Elrond and Durin. The best friendship in any Tolkien adaptation, Disa singing to the mountain, and what the Balrog does next.
Watch along with us
Season three premieres on Prime Video Wednesday, November 11, with multiple episodes dropping at once. Nick and I will hang out on Monday nights after each drop so you have time to watch twice. Every Tolkien conversation I’ve done, including our interviews with John Garth, Alan Sisto, and Tom Emmanuel and the Theology Beer Camp sessions with Craig Boyd, is now on its own Tolkien Heads podcast feed. Nick’s work lives at the Tolkien Pop Substack and podcast.
About Nick
Nick Polk is production editor of Mallorn, the journal of the Tolkien Society, and hosts Tolkien Pop. He slid into my DMs years ago when I asked if anyone liked both theology and Tolkien, and we’ve been co-hosting Tolkien Heads, teaching Tolkien classes, and running the Tolkien session at Theology Beer Camp ever since.
Join me in Berlin for the Bonhoeffer Travel Learning Trip
In June 2027, Andy Root and I are leading two Rise of Bonhoeffer travel-learning weeks. The Seminar (June 12–17) reads Bonhoeffer’s sources where they were fought over — Luther in Wittenberg, Schleiermacher and Barth in Berlin, the prison letters in his own house. The Pilgrimage (June 17–22) is for pastors and faith leaders, built around Bonhoeffer as a working minister in a time of resistance. Twenty-two seats each, back to back so you can do one or both. Early bird pricing through January 31. Details and registration at www.BonhoefferTrip.com
This podcast is a Homebrewed Christianity production. Follow the Homebrewed Christianity, Theology Nerd Throwdown, & The Rise of Bonhoeffer podcasts for more theological goodness for your earbuds. Join over 75,000others on our Substack – Process This! Get instant access to over 50 classes at www.TheologyClass.com
Follow the podcast, drop a review, send feedback/questions or become a member of the HBC Community.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download



