Andy Root is back. The last time he was on, he told progressive Christians they might need a little more heaven, and some of you are still emailing me about it. So we picked the fight back up, which works out nicely, because Advent opens with Isaiah begging God to tear the heavens open. This is a preview of the Advent class Andy and I are teaching. We think through the season with Charles Taylor, Hartmut Rosa, Byung-Chul Han, and Bonhoeffer, then take on the lectionary texts each week. It’s also a pitch for going back to Berlin together next June.

Andy makes his case for heaven by way of Augustine’s sermons on money. He thinks we can’t even have a healthy relationship with our 401(k) without some vision of the eternal. And heaven isn’t an escape hatch. It’s transcendence showing up as nearness. From there we get into Rosa’s snow, and the wonder of something arriving that you can’t control, right in the middle of the most accelerated month of the year. Then aufhören, stop and listen up, and Han on why scent forces you to linger and interpret. We also ask how you preach a Christmas Eve sermon to indifferent strangers without losing your job. Plus my most-cherished Christmas Eve memory, involving a $50 cigar, a $200 bottle of wine, Sam and Frodo, and some crying alone in the backyard.

Highlights from the conversation

  • Progressives need a little more heaven. Andy on Peter Brown’s The Ransom of the Soul, Augustine linking economic justice to a sense of heaven, why Martin Hägglund’s This Life doesn’t convince him, and Silicon Valley’s flat attempt to solve death.
  • Transcendence as nearness. Bonhoeffer’s prison letters and “only a suffering God can help,” heaven as a created realm where Christ’s body is, and why Advent shatters the flat Sunday-school picture.
  • Rosa’s snow. The Uncontrollability of the World opens with snowfall, the arrival of something you can’t control. Clergy know Advent as the least waiting-filled season of the year, so what does it mean to wait inside dynamic stabilization?
  • Christmas is where the family fights happen. The fantasy of the perfect gathering turns into a drive to control it, while the story itself is full of aggression: Herod, the cross, Mary’s song about tearing down the powerful.
  • Stop and listen up. Rosa’s aufhören, the word God uses on the Mount of Transfiguration, and the difference between anxious listening and receptive listening.
  • Terrifying before it’s comforting. Bonhoeffer and Barth’s Advent sermons, and how the precious-moments nativity numbs us to the inversion the story announces.
  • Preaching to indifferent strangers. Not cultured despisers, just people who don’t know the story. Andy’s goal for Christmas Eve: let people leave shocked, like seeing The Empire Strikes Back for the first time.
  • Advent should smell like something. Han on information vs. narration, scent as the sense that demands interpretation and can’t be accelerated, Schleiermacher’s Christmas Eve dialogue, and yes, the silent-but-deadly joke.

Join our Advent class

Tear Open the Heavens: Advent for Indifferent Strangers is a four-week online class Andy and I are teaching from Advent 1 (November 29) through Advent 4 (December 20).

  • Lectures: four pre-recorded lectures, two from each of us, each released the week before its Sunday. The first drops Monday, November 16.
  • Live conversations: five 70-minute livestreams at 10am PT / 1pm ET on November 24, December 1, 8, and 15, plus a Christmas Eve session on December 17. We unpack the thinkers and wrestle with that week’s lectionary text.
  • Readings and replays: a 30–40 page reading packet each week, a community space, and replays on the class resource page for at least a year.
  • Price: donation-based, including 0.

It’s timed so you can use it for your small group, Sunday school, or sermon that same week. Sign up at homebrewedclasses.com

Come to Berlin with us in 2027

Andy and I are leading two back-to-back sessions of the Rise of Bonhoeffer travel-learning experience in Berlin. Each one is capped at 22 people. Do one or both, or bring a few people from your church to the second.

  • Session One, June 12–17: Bonhoeffer’s Sources and His German Afterlife. A seminar on the thinkers who shaped Bonhoeffer (Luther, Schleiermacher, Hegel, the Luther Renaissance) and the postwar debates over his prison letters, with a day trip to Wittenberg. You don’t need a PhD, just a willingness to read.
  • Session Two, June 17–22: A Pastor’s Struggle in a Time of Resistance. A pilgrimage through Bonhoeffer’s Berlin, with teaching at the Bonhoeffer Haus and visits to Grunewald, the Topography of Terror, and the Martin Niemöller House. Built for pastors, chaplains, church staff, seminarians, and lay leaders.

Early-bird pricing runs through January 31, 2027. Details and registration are at bonhoeffertrip.com.

Andrew Root is the Carrie Olson Baalson Professor of Youth and Family Ministry at Luther Seminary, USA. He writes and researches in areas of theology, ministry, culture, and younger generations. Some of his most recent books are The Congregation in a Secular Age (Baker, 2021), The End of Youth Ministry? (Baker, 2020), The Pastor in a Secular Age: Ministry to People Who No Longer Need God (Baker, 2019), Faith Formation in a Secular Age (Baker, 2017), and Exploding Stars, Dead Dinosaurs, and Zombies: Youth Ministry in the Age of Science (Fortress Press, 2018). Andy has worked in congregations, parachurch ministries, and social service programs. He lives in St. Paul with his wife Kara, two children, Owen and Maisy, and their dog. When not reading, writing, or teaching, Andy spends far too much time watching TV and movies.

Previous Visits with Andy Root

This podcast is a Homebrewed Christianity production. Follow the Homebrewed Christianity, Theology Nerd Throwdown, & The Rise of Bonhoeffer podcasts for more theological goodness for your earbuds. Join over 75,000 others on our Substack – Process This! Get instant access to over 50 classes at www.TheologyClass.com

Follow the podcast, drop a review, send feedback/questions or become a member of the HBC Community.

X